Hello dear
Welcome to Old Bill Bailey's
Old Bill Bailey's, located in Lancaster, OH, is a beloved local gem known for its vibrant atmosphere and hearty menu. Specializing in comfort food, their standout offerings include the famously grilled chicken wings, assorted appetizers like breaded baby portabellas, and a variety of delicious burgers. Patrons appreciate the inviting outdoor patio, which enhances the dining experience. While the service is often highlighted for its friendliness, some seek added entertainment options like pool tables. Overall, Old Bill Bailey's provides a warm and welcoming vibe, perfect for enjoying great food and camaraderie in this small-town setting.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Breaded Baby Portabellas
Mushroom Onion Swiss Burger
Medium Buffalo
Cajun
About
Old Bill Bailey's
Welcome to Old Bill Bailey's, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Lancaster, Ohio, at 200 Harrison Ave. This lively establishment is a beloved gathering spot for locals and visitors alike, known for its delicious food, welcoming atmosphere, and friendly service.
At Old Bill Bailey's, the star of the show is undoubtedly the chicken wings. Patrons rave about the array of flavors from traditional Buffalo to the unique garlic Parmesan. Enthusiasts claim these wings might just be the best in the state, all thanks to the magic of their perfectly crafted grill. You can also indulge in a diverse selection of burgers, including the iconic Signature Bailey Burger and the savory Mushroom Onion Swiss Burger. Complement your meal with standout sandwiches like the Fish Tail or the Chicken Bacon Ranch, providing a delightful twist to your traditional bar fare.
But beyond the menu, what truly sets Old Bill Bailey's apart is its vibrant community feel. With ample outdoor seating, it's the perfect venue to enjoy great food in a relaxed, breezy environment. The bartenders are noted for their excellent service, and while one may possess a bit of a surly demeanor, patrons have found this adds to the charm of the place. Reviews highlight that the ambiance is typically peaceful, ideal for unwinding after a long day.
Of course, no review would be complete without a nod to the detailed offerings of house-made sauces that accompany their wings. Choices like the Crazy, Hot & Spicy Garlic, and Korean BBQ ensure that your taste buds are in for a thrilling ride. Customers echo sentiments of having found a slice of familiarity and comfort food despite being in an unfamiliar neighborhood. But beware—the absence of entertainment options, like a pool table, has left some patrons yearning for a bit more engaging fun.
In conclusion, Old Bill Bailey's is not just a place to eat; it’s a celebration of community through food, drink, and camaraderie. Whether you're digging into a succulent burger or savoring their famed wings, you’re bound to find a taste of something special. So head on down to Lancaster and let Old Bill Bailey's become your new favorite hangout.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ best chicken wings in the county and maybe the whole state. the magic is in the grill!burgers, nachos, fried pickles and shrooms are also great. good bartenders too, even the surly one. the outdoor patio is most excellent! ”
“ It had been a while since I have been there their wings used to be saucy there was barely any sauce in the wings but they were still good I just prefer mine messy The waitress was very nice and helpful it was quiet and peaceful. ”
“ We are originally from Western NY where the first chicken wings were brought into being at Frank and Theresa's Anchor Bar in the corner of Main and North. Haven't been able to find wings in all of Ohio or Tennessee where we lived briefly before moving to the Columbus area. Discovered Old Bill Bailey's from a work associate. Great wings. They are a little pricey but worth it. They have Buffalo wings, garlic Parmesan, a maple flavored offering and a couple of sweeter flavored choices. We have had the Buffalo and garlic Parmesan and they were very good. Place is located in an iffy neighborhood in Lancaster but never had a problem there. ”
“ Seriously Disappointed - Where's the Fun at Old Bill Bailey's?! Listen, I went to Old Bill Bailey's in Lancaster expecting a decent neighborhood bar vibe. What I got was... well, just "bar." And not a particularly exciting one at that. The biggest letdown? NO POOL TABLE. Seriously? In this day and age, a bar without a pool table feels like a restaurant without fries. It's a staple! My friends and I were looking forward to shooting some pool, having a few drinks, and just generally having a good time. Instead, we were met with a gaping void where a glorious eight-ball table should have been. We ended up just nursing our beers, feeling utterly bored. The atmosphere was... fine, I guess. Nothing special to write home about. But the complete absence of any engaging entertainment, specifically a pool table, left a really sour taste in my mouth. What are people supposed to do here besides just sit and stare at each other? Make awkward small talk? Old Bill Bailey's, you need to seriously consider adding a pool table. It's a basic requirement for a decent bar in my book, and its absence makes your establishment feel dull and frankly, not worth a return visit. There are plenty of other places in Lancaster where I can actually do something while I have a drink. Don't waste your time here if you're looking for any kind of fun beyond just sitting. Huge thumbs down for the lack of a pool table. Get with the program! ”
“ Old Bill Baileys is a Lancaster gathering place .For excellent food and drink.Small town atmosphere with entertainment. There is a huge outside seating space. The staff treats all who visit with the most courteous and professional service above and beyond normal. It's a small town gem. ”
“ Service was great and the atmosphere was awesome. Live music was really good and the nachos were the best! ”
“ We had a blast. We played darts. (I won.....of course. Lol) I got a little tipsy, and will definitely be going back! ”
“ Great hometown bar! Food and service spot on. Wings are touched on the grill before sauce is added for a different taste and texture. ”